Given the length of my review of the 2012 edition of Dogfish Head's Weekend of Compelling Ales and What Not, I thought it prudent to separate my tasting notes from the day into a separate entry. Each of the fifteen beers featured at the festival in Milton will be accompanied by a photo of the information placard that was found at its respective pour location. I would have loved to have reviewed the ones from the brewpub in Rehoboth Beach as well, but in the interest of full disclosure, I can remember only bits and pieces about the beers (I had had sixteen samples by the time I got to the brewpub) and so I cannot in good conscience attempt to rate or describe them to any great degree.
The order of the WOCAAW beers will reflect that of which we consumed them, not the order in which they appear on the souvenir beer log card. The grades for each beer represent the grade that I applied in my beer list, while the position number refers to its status as a favorite out of the fifteen beers from the event.
#1 Red & White (2011)
Red & White has always been one of those middle-of-the-road beers for me--one of the few that hasn't truly
wowed me from Dogfish Head. With that said, the version on tap at the event seemed a little bit smoother than the bottled version that I had had previously and featured much sweeter, more nuanced flavors. There was a certain wine-like quality to it that likely came from the pinot noir juice that is used in the fermentation process. It is undoubtedly recognizable as a witbier, mostly because of the spices (coriander and orange peel), but its overall flavor spectrum is harder to pin down. Most witbiers live and die by their spice profiles whereas the Red & White utilizes its spices more as a complement to the vinous fruit elements that make up its body. Overall, a very enjoyable brew and a great way to start off the day.
My grade: A-
Position: 13 / 15
# 2 Black & Blue (2011)
Much like the Red & White, the Black & Blue enjoys a relatively high alcohol content for its style (10.00% for both, a witbier and a fruit / vegetable beer, respectively). The latter, however, makes a left turn from the former in its flavors. Powerful fruit/berry notes rise from the glass in its bouquet and coats the mouth during the taste. Its Belgian base can be witnessed both in the color and in the underlying flavors, particularly as it pertains to the yeast. Still, the fruit is what demands attention. Many beers of this style suffer from the "too much of a good thing" issue but Black & Blue enjoys a balanced panoply of flavors that begins and ends with the berries and also contains a welcome tartness.
Black & Blue was paired with some delectable Askinosie chocolate and, as such, that must be taken into account for its tasting. I found that taking a small bite of the chocolate and then a sip of the beer with the chocolate still in my mouth made for a divine tasting experience. Sipping the beer and then eating the chocolate also worked as they served to complement and bolster each other nicely. Definitely a solid pairing.
My Grade: A-
Position: 11 / 15
#3 120 Minute IPA (2011)
My co-#1 beer from last year was the 120 Minute IPA that I had at the Analog-A-Go-Go and the regular 120 Minute came in at #11. This year, the 2011 vintage almost stole the show again. It was slightly smoother than the standard 120 Minute but the warm combination of syrupy hops and alcohol still dominate the palette. What made this beer so interesting this time around, though, was its pairing with the manchego cheese. This awesome sample had a buttery earthiness to it that paired
extremely well with the 120 Minute. In a way, it brought out the earthy characteristics of the hops and smoothed out the syrupy alcohol notes that came through. I'm curious as to how well the cheese would have paired with, say, the Chateau Jiahu or Ta Henket but it was a home run as far as I'm concerned with the 120 Minute.
My Grade: A+
Position: 2 / 15
#4 Immort Ale (2011)
The Immort Ale was one of my least favorite brews of the day. On its own, it's an excellent beer and the powerful assortment of flavors meld together finely but as a part of the festival, it seemed out of place. I feel like you could have gone from any one beer to any other and it would have been a smooth, seamless transition but going from nearly any beer to the Immort Ale just wouldn't have worked. The peat-smoked barley gave it a strong scotch-like character that would have been pleasant in isolation but I think it was just too jarring to follow up the other milder, smoother beers with. I think that a better pairing might have been the El Diablo Verde (and by pairing I mean table-mate) because of the flavor palette of the latter beer. Ultimately, though I have enjoyed the Immort Ale before, I didn't appreciate it fully as a part of the WOCAAW.
My Grade: A-
Position: 14 / 15
#5 Namaste
Another witbier, Namaste offers a
very different experience from the Red & White. This brew adheres more closely to the traditional definition of a witbier, especially with its stronger, sweeter orange overtones and coriander foundation. The addition of lemongrass gives it a competing citrus aspect that simultaneously works with and vies against the orange. It also offers a more floral scent to the beer that I found appealing.
Namaste was paired with goat cheese, which, for me, was a new one. I don't have much experience with that type of cheese and so it was a bit of an exploration process for me. The cheese itself was good but it went from having a cottage cheese consistency to a cream cheese one while I had it in my mouth, which, in and of itself, was quite strange. It didn't really seem to do much for or against the beer but it could just be because my cheese palette is not all that advanced. Overall, a really good beer and a decent pairing.
My Grade: A-
Position: 10 / 15
#6 Sah'tea
The Sah'tea is one of my all-time favorite Dogfish Head beers. The fact that it's a representation of a style that dates back to the 9th century just adds to the beer's mystique and allure. I love the complex spice profile that comprises some interesting additions such as cardamom and juniper berries. The thing that I enjoy most about it though is the black tea flavor; it's unlike anything I've ever had in a beer. A sip of this beer yields a variety of flavors all contributed by the spices, the rest of which include cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and black pepper. This seemingly motley mix of ingredients works
amazingly well together and being able to have this beer on tap was an unforgettable treat for me.
My Grade: A+
Position: 6 / 15
#7 Chateau Jiahu
I had forgotten just how much I loved this beer until I had it at the WOCAAW. The Ancient Ales line of beers are among my favorite Dogfish Head offerings and the Chateau Jiahu might just be my second favorite behind the Sah'tea (the Theobroma is in close contention for that spot). Chateau is based on a style of beer that is
9,000 years old. NINE THOUSAND! It's a delicious mix of wine-like flavors but much sweeter and palatable than the Red & White and similar brews. The marriage of muscat grapes, hawthorn berries, and orange honey blossoms makes for a deceptively smooth and balanced brew. This is one of those "if you haven't tasted it yet go out and buy a bottle
now" beers. Tremendous!
My Grade: A+
Position: 7 / 15
#8 Ta Henket
Ta Henket is another Herbed / Spiced beer that is a part of the Ancient Ales line. Unfortunately, for as unique as it is, it doesn't offer nearly as much in the way of desirable flavors as its brethren. The WOCAAW version seemed overly yeasty and biscuity. There was clearly a smattering of other flavors battling for attention but, all in all, it just tasted like liquid bread. Maybe it was just that something was taken away from it because it followed the Chateau Jiahu (which was awesome), maybe it wasn't a good fit for the event, or maybe I'm just no longer a big fan of the brew. Either way, I was ultimately underwhelmed by this one.
My Grade: B+
Position: 15 / 15
#9 My Antonia
I've always had an ambivalent relationship with My Antonia with one exception: I had a bottle that was brewed in conjunction with Italian brewer Birra Del Borgo, which was
phenomenal. The regular edition of the beer is touted as a lager for ale lovers but I'm not sure that it's an accurate description. I am, without question, an ale lover but I do enjoy lagers as well. With that said, I like those lagers to offer something
different from the ales (after all, it's the reason I'm drinking them) but My Antonia seems to be almost too close to being an ale for my liking. Instead of being a solid lager that will appeal to ale lovers, it strikes me more as an attempt at a crossover type of brew. It's sweet and smooth but it's ultimately a one-note beer for me.
What was cool about the WOCAAW version of the My Antonia, though, was that it was paired with an awesome pretzel that was provided by the Dolce Bakery. They used Dogfish Head's spent grain to make the pretzels, which is an example of a wonderful and environmentally conscious attempt to try to make the most out of every part of the brewing process. The pretzel was
delicious and was just what I needed at that point in the day. It paired well with the My Antonia but, again, it didn't bowl me over like the manchego did or the apricot cheese.
My Grade: A-
Position: 12 / 15
#10 Aprihop
Aprihop was one of my most pleasant surprises of the day. I had mistakenly associated the Festina Peche in my mind with the Aprihop and so when I took my first sip I was blown away by the incredible (and unexpectedly unexpected) flavor profile. It melds the best of an imperial IPA with the sweet-but-not-cloying flavors of apricots. It reminded me a lot of one of my
other top beers of 2011, which was a mango IPA. The Aprihop, as an IPA, is actually
better than the Mango Mama but the fruitiness of the latter was a little bit more enjoyable.
The Aprihop was paired with this
ridiculously good cheese that was made with apricots. It was a crumbly cheese with bits of apricots infused within. Oh man...it was, hands down, the best cheese I've ever had. I wish only that they would have offered a name for it or at least a place that I might be able to find it. I would
love to do an Aprihop/apricot cheese pairing again in the future at my leisure. Tied for the best pairing of the day and easily one of my favorite beers.
My Grade: A+
Position: 5 / 15
*NOTE: Beers eleven through fifteen do not have information placards; three were offered inside the brewery gift shop while the other two were poured near the small batch demonstration area outside.
#11 Midas Jitos
Midas Jitos was one of the more interesting beers of the day. It was Midas Touch run through a Randall of limes and mint, thus transforming it into a mojito-esque beer (hence the name). Midas Touch by itself is an awesome beer that combines the sweetness of mead with the tart acidity of wine; the Randallized version took these variegated flavor elements and slammed them together, thus melding them with the cool, refreshing mint and the refreshing citrus notes of the limes. It's definitely a beer that I would love to get my hands on in the summer as it would be the perfect quaff for an afternoon spent relaxing on the beach. It's delicate enough to stand up to a summer evening's toast but thirst-quenching and flavorful enough to be enjoyable beneath the relentless summer sun. Delicious!
My Grade: A
Position: 8 / 15
#12 Dirty Fermentini
Part of why I love Dogfish Head is the way that it experiments fearlessly and unapologetically with flavors and ingredients. Some brewers that use "extreme" ingredients do so as a way of flexing some sort of muscle, basically beating their fans over the head with the attitude that "they (the fans) will try anything we make because they are devoted to us." Dogfish Head, as a brewery, also brews with its fans in mind but it's always been more of a "hey, we're trying this out, why don't you join us?" sort of angle. It's a huge part of what appeals to me about the brewery and is something that is clearly evident in beers like Dirty Fermentini.
Dirty Fermentini boasts an audacious array of ingredients that are essentially based upon those that would be found in a dirty martini, with olives and juniper leading the charge. Hoppy, peppery notes also bleed through but it is the characteristic olive flavor that dominates. This one is a you-have-to-taste-it-to-believe-it type of beer and was one of the highlights of the day for me.
My Grade: A-
Position: 9 / 15
#13 Palo Santo Marron
Palo Santo is another beer that I forgot how much I enjoyed. It's an awesome, sweet brown ale that enjoys an almost-bourbon barrel aged-like quality to it in the form of strong vanilla and caramel notes. There is an undeniable earthy/oak-like quality to it (it's
not oak but I don't know how to categorize it) that comes from the fact that it is aged in vessels made of Palo Santo wood. If you're a fan of brown ales and bourbon barrel aged beers, then you should definitely give this one a whirl. It's dark, powerful (12.00% abv!), sweet, luscious...just amazing. Another highlight from the event!
My Grade: A+
Position: 4 / 15
#14 El Diablo Verde
My number one brew from the WOCAAW and one of the best of this young beer year. It's unlike anything I've ever had before. It was paired with these delicious nachos and it complemented them better than any other pairing (except for the Aprihop...but it's close). In a way, it was almost as if the beer was an ingredient
in the nachos. If you loaded up on the fixin's, took a bite of the nachos, then a sip of the beer, you'd feel like you just had a complete tasting experience. The beer was brewed with
jalapeño
s and cilantro, both of which come through loud and clear and yet work perfectly with the imperial IPA base. The spicy, hoppy IPA couples with the two aforementioned ingredients to turn the beer, effectively, into some sort of mind-blowing liquid nachos. The fact that this beer was an employee collaboration makes it even more exciting because it could portend of even more unforgettable beers to come. Easily my favorite beer of the day amid a crowd of
very strong competitors.
My Grade: A+
Position: 1 / 15
#15 Burton Baton
I took a sip of my Burton Baton sample, put it down, went into the gift shop, and bought a four pack to take home. There aren't many beers that can have that type of impact on me but this one clearly did. An oak aged blend of an English old ale and an imperial American IPA!? Are you kidding me!? AWESOME doesn't even begin to describe it. It's mellow, it's sweet, it's hoppy (in that wonderful Northwest way), and, best of all, it's
smooth. Drinking Burton Baton is like listening to Barry White read you a bedtime story. Done.
My Grade: A+
Position: 3 / 15
The Weekend of Compelling Ales and What Not was an
awesome time and I'm truly looking forward to attending (hopefully) the Analog-A-Go-Go later this year. There might be only one thing that Dogfish Head does better than brew beer and that would be throwing an incredible party. Thanks again and cheers to everyone there for making this such an unforgettable weekend!
--Beer Whisperer Matt